Will rising oil prices help Texas?
The article seems to imply that the Texas economy and state budget will be helped by high oil prices. Wrong.
Rising oil prices will keep Tx relatively better off then other states, but the economy will still get worse. Anyway, it is likely that most of the oil income leaves the state - Exxon stock is not owned exclusively by Texans.
"If Combs' early forecast holds up, Gov. Rick Perry would like to return part of the money to the taxpayers in the form of tax cuts or rebate checks, spokesman Robert Black said."
So the people who don't work for oil and gas can afford to fill up their tanks? (Can't have the money as a reserve for a rainy day, gotta get it out there where it can find the quickest route to wall street, china and Saudi Arabia, and Exxon.)
So if gasoline goes up to $10 a gallon, Texas will be doing just fantastic, even better than ever, right? No, this statement is the usual superficial bull from politicians.
The US uses 21 million barrels of oil a day. Texas produces 1.1 million barrels of oil a day. (The US produces 5M) https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2174rank.html http://tonto.eia.doe.gov/dnav/pet/pet_crd_crpdn_adc_mbbl_a.htm 21 / 300 million us population = .07 million barrels/day per million people Texas population = 23 million X .07 = 1.61 million barrels/day used by Texans (if you assume that Texans use an average amount of oil, which with big cars, long distances and little public transport is unlikely)
Texas isn't even energy independent, and it is the highest producing US state. Texas is a net buyer of more expensive oil, higher oil prices will hurt not help. Texas has diversified away from Oil in any case, and it is dependent of the rest of the US and world economy.
Besides, the reason the price is going up is because demand is exceeding supply. If Tx has extra bucks, it should spend it on something useful like alternatives.
(The first link above in interesting. I find it fascinating that all of Asia, with 3+ billion people uses the same amount of oil as the US, with 300 million.)
'But, he added, the governor wants to keep Texas' economic engine "going and growing."'
Not gonna happen, Gov. The economy cannot grow while energy use declines or stays stagnant. However, if you want to play math games with economic statistics, maybe then you can call it growth ...
Government statistics on employment and economic growth are political documents, not reliable data.
Employment data uses the birth-death model to add hundreds of thousands of non-existent jobs: http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/2007/05/birth-death-model-fatally-flawed.html
Inflation is underreported for many, many reasons. Therefore, since economic growth is adjusted for inflation, economic growth is routinely exaggerated.
So, if you read that the Texas or US economy is growing, take that with a grain of salt.
Labels: economic statistics, economy, oil, Texas